ok so i follow jap pop culture news regularly on
aramatheydidnt and
japan_now , and some things which are seriously irking me include posts by haterz. OK, it's a pop culture news community. Being the internetz, and being followed by mainly people my age, I don't expect like, perfect neutrality or objectivity (well, even though all they do is repost articles from other sources, but even then...) That being said, the main way they seem to express their bias is through the titles of their posts, which the mods seem to have ignored significantly, especially on
aramatheydidnt . And the hater and the flaming kind of seriously pisses me off, even when it's not my fandom or anything.
In particular there's a certain user who is a self-proclaimed SNSD fan (well, it's kind of obvious *cough*). Many of her posts have kind of seriously weird titles which no one seems to get (aside from the said poster), such as "GLAWLESS GENERATION" (Glawless...Flawless...Girls' Generation...geddit? =.=) and well yeah fine, i'm OK if you post such things on your blog, but on a community? WTF please. I know I'm sounding thoroughly bitchy here, but seriously, after all the hate over there? NOWHERE IN COMPARISON PLS. In addition, I'm willing to tolerate that itch to change the title if it's biased towards someone (i.e. positive), but when it flames other people's fandoms? Not cool. OK, maybe I'm a bit fired up because she attacked my personal fandom, in a title called "NIPPON KNOWS TRASH", (which is a seriously lousy attempt, worse than glawless generation, at replacing "Nippon no Arashi...") Firstly, the article was on a pretty positive note. Basically last year, the government commissioned the Arashi members as tourist navigators of Japan, and the result of that was a textbook produced by their Ministry of Education for their Social Studies (or the equivalent, I'm writing this off the top of my head so... ><), featuring the Arashi members. Being relatively popular in Japan now, I think the government's hope was that they would interest the kids in picking up their textbook. The book was distributed to about 40,000 schools, and became a crazy, sought-after-like-never-before limited-edition thing which was priced at a bomb on ebay. The book was never meant for public sale. However in the light of the Tohoku earthquake disaster earlier this year, it was decided that the book would be downsized and sold to the public, with all proceeds going towards disaster relief. I think recognising the siao-ness of the craze over the book, whoever came up with this saw it as an opportunity to get lots of $$ and help those in the Tohoku area. BUT beyond that - given the nature of the article highlighted in the post, I think the title is highly irreverent and frankly immature and childish - not just to the Japanese government or the agency or even Arashi themselves - but even in a sense disrespectful to those affected by the Tohoku disaster. Those people are living hand-to-mouth, day by day, and you call any small effort to help them return to their daily lives trash? It's like calling the Red Cross trash. You just don't do it.
I have absolutely no clue why the poster chose to do this. If you want to go on about how your Korean darlings pwn Japan, please, save it for
omonatheydidnt , where at least there may be more people who commiserate with you. Don't bring your crap and throw it around just because you feel like it.
In other words, not pleased. Not sure how others following the comm feel, but if that poster were to be banned, I would feel a sadistic sense of satisfaction and glee. The reason why I'm posting this on my personal LJ rather than the comm is purely because i don't want to get caught up in all the bitchiness of the comm right now. But seriously, whoever that person is needs to thoroughly think through their actions - from coming up with weird titles which just confuse people to putting on this Korean-elitism attitude in her comments, to focusing on the grammar slips of people who are unhappy with what she's doing - it all comes across as highly immature and doesn't add to her cred at all.
PS No offense to the KPop communty or to the Korean community! I do like SNSD and although I don't really follow KPop, i get the idea that most of the kpop idols/bands/groups are as sweet and hardworking and deserving of the popularity they are getting now, as the japan groups i like. Hope I don't come across as holding a 'jap-is-better' attitude ><
In particular there's a certain user who is a self-proclaimed SNSD fan (well, it's kind of obvious *cough*). Many of her posts have kind of seriously weird titles which no one seems to get (aside from the said poster), such as "GLAWLESS GENERATION" (Glawless...Flawless...Girls' Generation...geddit? =.=) and well yeah fine, i'm OK if you post such things on your blog, but on a community? WTF please. I know I'm sounding thoroughly bitchy here, but seriously, after all the hate over there? NOWHERE IN COMPARISON PLS. In addition, I'm willing to tolerate that itch to change the title if it's biased towards someone (i.e. positive), but when it flames other people's fandoms? Not cool. OK, maybe I'm a bit fired up because she attacked my personal fandom, in a title called "NIPPON KNOWS TRASH", (which is a seriously lousy attempt, worse than glawless generation, at replacing "Nippon no Arashi...") Firstly, the article was on a pretty positive note. Basically last year, the government commissioned the Arashi members as tourist navigators of Japan, and the result of that was a textbook produced by their Ministry of Education for their Social Studies (or the equivalent, I'm writing this off the top of my head so... ><), featuring the Arashi members. Being relatively popular in Japan now, I think the government's hope was that they would interest the kids in picking up their textbook. The book was distributed to about 40,000 schools, and became a crazy, sought-after-like-never-before limited-edition thing which was priced at a bomb on ebay. The book was never meant for public sale. However in the light of the Tohoku earthquake disaster earlier this year, it was decided that the book would be downsized and sold to the public, with all proceeds going towards disaster relief. I think recognising the siao-ness of the craze over the book, whoever came up with this saw it as an opportunity to get lots of $$ and help those in the Tohoku area. BUT beyond that - given the nature of the article highlighted in the post, I think the title is highly irreverent and frankly immature and childish - not just to the Japanese government or the agency or even Arashi themselves - but even in a sense disrespectful to those affected by the Tohoku disaster. Those people are living hand-to-mouth, day by day, and you call any small effort to help them return to their daily lives trash? It's like calling the Red Cross trash. You just don't do it.
I have absolutely no clue why the poster chose to do this. If you want to go on about how your Korean darlings pwn Japan, please, save it for
In other words, not pleased. Not sure how others following the comm feel, but if that poster were to be banned, I would feel a sadistic sense of satisfaction and glee. The reason why I'm posting this on my personal LJ rather than the comm is purely because i don't want to get caught up in all the bitchiness of the comm right now. But seriously, whoever that person is needs to thoroughly think through their actions - from coming up with weird titles which just confuse people to putting on this Korean-elitism attitude in her comments, to focusing on the grammar slips of people who are unhappy with what she's doing - it all comes across as highly immature and doesn't add to her cred at all.
PS No offense to the KPop communty or to the Korean community! I do like SNSD and although I don't really follow KPop, i get the idea that most of the kpop idols/bands/groups are as sweet and hardworking and deserving of the popularity they are getting now, as the japan groups i like. Hope I don't come across as holding a 'jap-is-better' attitude ><
Current Mood:
aggravated
aggravated3 comments | Leave a comment
frustrated
disappointed
thoughtful
nervous
əˌnaɪn
sleepyy
accomplished